I haven't played or even opened a pack yet (waiting to do that with my friends in a couple weeks), but I read the downloadable rules. I don't understand what problem Rick Thornquist had with them. I found them simple enough. In fact, a little too simple. I know this is supposed to be a fast & light game, but I'm disappointed that a game about sailing ships has no concept of wind or broadsides.
I haven't looked at this, mainly because it is collectible. Does that aspect not bother you?
Posted by: Dave Wilson at August 23, 2004 09:56 AMNope. I only bought four packs, which gets me 8 ships and a variety of other pieces (treasure, islands, crew). That's enough to play, and I find it fun to spend another $4 every once in a while to get a little more stuff. Or not. No problem with me.
Posted by: Mark Johnson at August 23, 2004 03:29 PM